MDR vs EDR vs Antivirus: What Does a Small Business Actually Need?

The honest difference between antivirus, EDR and MDR, which attacks each one catches, and what an Irish business of 10 to 200 staff should run.

By the ERS IT Solutions team Updated 16 November 2026 5 min read

A small business needs EDR on every device plus someone watching it, which is what managed detection and response provides. Antivirus alone catches known malware and little else. EDR records what happens on each device and can spot and contain suspicious behaviour, but it generates alerts that someone has to read and act on, at 3am as well as 3pm. MDR is EDR plus a team of analysts who investigate, respond and report. For an Irish business without a security team, MDR is the realistic way to get the benefit of EDR. ERS IT Solutions in Dublin 15 provides MDR to organisations of all sizes.

What is antivirus?

Antivirus (or anti-malware) scans files and programs against known signatures and some behavioural rules, and blocks or quarantines what it recognises. Every Windows device has Microsoft Defender Antivirus built in, and it is good at what it does. Its limits are the point: it works best against malware it has seen before, it looks at one device at a time, and it does not tell anyone when an attacker logs in with a stolen password and uses legitimate tools. Most serious attacks on SMEs now start with a compromised account, not a virus.

What is EDR?

Endpoint detection and response records activity on each device (processes, network connections, file changes, logins), looks for patterns that indicate an attack, and lets a responder isolate the device, kill processes and roll back changes. It catches things antivirus misses: a legitimate admin tool used to spread across the network, a script that disables backups, an unusual login at 2am. Microsoft Defender for Business is an EDR product for businesses up to 300 users; it is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and is a €2.60 per user per month add-on to other plans on Microsoft's Irish list (Microsoft business plans).

The catch: EDR produces alerts, and alerts need a person. An unread alert is no better than no alert. EDR also only sees the endpoints it is installed on, not your Microsoft 365 tenant, your firewall or your cloud apps.

What is MDR?

Managed detection and response is a service, not a product. A provider runs the EDR platform and other sensors, correlates logs across endpoints, servers, cloud apps and the network, and has analysts who hunt for threats, investigate alerts, cut false positives and respond when something is real. The output is action and reports, not a dashboard you have to watch. ERS's MDR service covers ransomware, phishing follow-on activity, lateral movement and insider threats, with forensic and root-cause analysis after an incident and audit-ready documentation.

MDR vs EDR vs antivirus: side by side

AntivirusEDRMDR
What it isSoftware on each deviceSoftware on each device with recording and response toolsA service: EDR plus analysts, monitoring and response
CatchesKnown malwareSuspicious behaviour on devicesSuspicious behaviour across devices, cloud and network, investigated by people
Who respondsThe software, automaticallyYour IT team, if they see the alertThe provider's analysts, 24/7
Sees Microsoft 365 account takeoverNoPartly, if the device is involvedYes, with Microsoft 365 monitoring
Out-of-hours coverAutomatic blocking onlyOnly if someone is on callYes
False positivesFew, but misses muchMany, and someone must triageTriaged by analysts before you are involved
Typical costIncluded with WindowsPer device per month; Defender for Business €2.60 on Microsoft's Irish listPer device or per user per month, quoted
SuitsHome users; a baseline on every deviceBusinesses with an in-house security teamBusinesses without a security team, which is most Irish SMEs

What does a small business actually need?

For a business of 10 to 200 staff with no security team, which describes most Irish SMEs:

  1. Antivirus on every device. You already have it in Windows. Keep it on and updated.
  2. EDR on every device. If you are on Microsoft 365 Business Premium you already own Defender for Business; it needs to be deployed and configured. See Business Premium vs Business Standard.
  3. Someone watching it. Either an in-house person on call around the clock, or an MDR service. For an SME the MDR service is cheaper than the person.
  4. Identity monitoring. Because the attack usually starts with a stolen password, add monitoring of your Microsoft 365 tenant for impossible travel logins, rogue OAuth apps and inbox rule changes.
  5. Backups that are isolated and tested. Detection reduces damage; backups are what get you back. See our ransomware protection guide.

A business with its own IT team can run EDR itself during office hours and use MDR for out-of-hours cover and escalation, which is how co-managed IT clients often work with ERS.

How much does managed detection and response cost for a small business?

MDR is priced per device or per user per month. The price depends on how many devices and users, whether servers and cloud apps are included, the response level you want and whether you already hold the Microsoft licences that provide the EDR layer. ERS quotes per business after a short call. If you are already paying for Business Premium, the EDR tooling cost is covered and you are paying for the monitoring and response.

Signs you have outgrown antivirus alone

  • Staff work remotely or on their own devices.
  • You hold customer personal data or move money on email instructions.
  • Your cyber insurer asks whether you have EDR or 24/7 monitoring.
  • Nobody would notice an unusual login at 2am until Monday morning.
  • You have been phished once already, even if nothing came of it.

Common questions

Does Microsoft Defender count as EDR?

Microsoft Defender Antivirus, built into Windows, is antivirus. Microsoft Defender for Business and Defender for Endpoint are EDR products with recording, investigation and response tools. Defender for Business is included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium and available as an add-on to other business plans. It still needs someone to watch and act on the alerts.

Can I have MDR without replacing my antivirus?

Yes. MDR usually runs on top of an EDR agent, and Defender Antivirus keeps running alongside it. If you already own Defender for Business, an MDR service can often use it rather than installing another product, which keeps the cost down.

Is EDR enough without MDR?

Only if someone reads and acts on the alerts around the clock. EDR is a tool; MDR is the people and process that make the tool useful. Most Irish SMEs that buy EDR and nothing else end up with alerts nobody sees.

What about SOC as a service?

SOC as a service and MDR overlap heavily. Both mean an outside team monitoring your environment and responding. MDR usually stresses the endpoint and response part; a SOC service may stress log collection and compliance reporting. Ask what sensors are included, who responds, how fast and what you receive in writing.

Does MDR stop ransomware?

It reduces the chance that an attacker gets far enough to deploy ransomware, by catching the earlier steps: the phishing login, the privilege escalation, the attempt to disable backups. Nothing stops every attack, which is why isolated, tested backups and a continuity plan still matter.

Questions about managed detection and response? Talk to the ERS team.

Unit 5, Block 8, Blanchardstown Corporate Park, Dublin 15. Supporting Irish organisations since 1983.